Stefanie Fair: Wild Orchid Singer Receives $70,000 Settlement After Sober DUI Arrest in Nashville

 
By zen , 19 November 2026
Stefanie Fair

Stefanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s girl group Wild Orchid, is set to receive $70,000 from the state of Tennessee following a lawsuit over her 2024 DUI arrest. The settlement was approved by the Tennessee Board of Claims after laboratory testing showed that she had no alcohol or drugs in her system when she was arrested.

The incident involved Tennessee Highway Patrol (THP) Trooper Keith Velez, who stopped Fair in Nashville on June 23, 2024. He claimed to smell alcohol and subsequently arrested her after conducting roadside sobriety tests.

Fair repeatedly denied drinking alcohol. Her blood test later supported her account, and the DUI charge was dismissed. The settlement has renewed attention to a wider series of allegations involving sober drivers arrested by Tennessee law enforcement officers.

Who Is Stefanie Fair?

Stefanie Fair, also identified as Stephanie Fair in some local news reports, is an American singer and former television personality.

She became known during the 1990s as a member of Wild Orchid, a female pop group that included Fergie, who later achieved international fame as a member of the Black Eyed Peas.

Wild Orchid released music during the late 1990s, including songs such as "Talk to Me" and "At Night I Pray."

Fair later appeared in the Bravo reality television series There Goes the Motherhood, which followed a group of mothers navigating family life in Los Angeles.

She is married to music executive and producer Ron Fair, who previously served as president of A&M Records and worked with numerous well-known recording artists.

What Happened During Stefanie Fair's DUI Arrest?

The incident occurred on June 23, 2024, on Armory Drive in Nashville, Tennessee.

According to WSMV4 Investigates, Trooper Keith Velez stopped Fair because she had failed to move over while he was conducting another roadside traffic stop.

During their interaction, Velez told Fair that he detected a distinct smell of alcohol coming from her or her vehicle.

Fair strongly disputed the accusation, repeatedly explaining that she did not drink alcohol.

Body-camera footage obtained by WSMV4 captured the interaction, including Fair telling the trooper that she had never consumed alcohol.

Velez subsequently conducted field sobriety examinations and claimed that her performance indicated possible impairment.

One of the tests involved horizontal gaze nystagmus, an examination that looks for involuntary eye movements that can be associated with intoxication.

Velez interpreted the observations as signs of impairment and arrested Fair on suspicion of driving under the influence.

Blood Tests Showed No Alcohol or Drugs

The most important development came after Fair's arrest, when laboratory analysis was conducted on her blood sample.

According to WSMV4's investigation, the results showed no alcohol or drugs in her system.

The complete results became available approximately two months after the arrest.

Fair's attorney, Ben Raybin, also obtained video from a Brentwood establishment showing that she had been eating ice cream approximately an hour before the traffic stop.

The footage became relevant because it provided additional context about Fair's activities before she was stopped.

After the laboratory findings became available, the DUI charge was dismissed.

Fair subsequently described the arrest as frightening and questioned how a person who had not consumed alcohol could be subjected to such an experience.

What Did Trooper Keith Velez Say?

Trooper Keith Velez maintained during the traffic stop that he smelled alcohol coming from Fair or her vehicle.

In body-camera footage, he can also be heard discussing the incident with another trooper who arrived at the scene.

He described Fair's driving before the stop and reiterated his belief that the vehicle smelled of alcohol.

Fair, meanwhile, continued denying that she had been drinking.

Her subsequent lawsuit challenged the legal basis for the arrest and alleged violations of her constitutional rights, including protections against unreasonable searches and seizures.

The settlement announcement does not provide a judicial finding that Velez committed misconduct. The civil dispute was resolved through a settlement rather than a jury verdict.

Why Is Tennessee Paying Stefanie Fair $70,000?

Following the arrest and dismissal of the DUI charge, Fair pursued legal action seeking compensation for the consequences of the incident.

Her legal team argued that the arrest lacked sufficient legal justification, particularly in light of the subsequent blood-test results.

The Tennessee Board of Claims approved a $70,000 settlement in November 2026.

A spokesman for the Tennessee Attorney General's Office told WSMV4 that the payment was expected within the following weeks.

Case DetailInformation
ClaimantStefanie Fair
Age at settlement reporting53
Former music groupWild Orchid
Arrest dateJune 23, 2024
LocationArmory Drive, Nashville, Tennessee
Arresting officerTHP Trooper Keith Velez
Blood-test resultNo alcohol or drugs detected
DUI chargeDismissed
Approved settlement$70,000
Approval authorityTennessee Board of Claims

Fair's attorney, Ben Raybin, said the settlement reflected the problems associated with arrests that cannot be adequately supported by the available evidence.

Is Stefanie Fair the Only Sober Driver to Receive Compensation?

No. Fair is the second sober driver reported to have reached a financial settlement with the Tennessee Highway Patrol over a DUI arrest.

Another case involved Thomas Manis, who received $75,000 after being arrested for DUI in Monroe County, East Tennessee, in December 2023.

His lawsuit also challenged the basis for the arrest and sought compensation for the consequences of being accused of driving under the influence despite being sober.

WSMV4 Investigates has also reported on other drivers who have pursued legal action following similar incidents, including NASA employee Labreesha Batey and former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant.

These cases have raised questions about the reliability of roadside sobriety assessments and the procedures used by officers when deciding whether to make DUI arrests.

Why Are Sober DUI Arrests Becoming a Concern in Tennessee?

Fair's case forms part of a broader investigation by WSMV4 into arrests involving drivers whose subsequent testing showed no alcohol or drugs in their systems.

The investigation identified multiple lawsuits alleging that officers arrested sober drivers despite insufficient evidence of impairment.

One particularly concerning example involves Tennessee Highway Patrol Trooper James Zahn.

According to WSMV4's reporting, records and allegations in separate lawsuits suggest that Zahn arrested as many as nine drivers who were subsequently identified as sober.

Those allegations are being addressed through separate legal proceedings and should not be confused with Fair's case involving Trooper Velez.

The wider issue has prompted discussion about how law enforcement agencies evaluate suspected impairment, document field sobriety tests, and review arrests when laboratory evidence becomes available.

It also highlights the financial and reputational consequences that individuals may face even when criminal charges are eventually dismissed.

What Happens Next After the $70,000 Settlement?

The Tennessee Board of Claims has approved Fair's settlement, and the state expects to complete the payment within the next few weeks, according to the Attorney General's Office spokesman quoted by WSMV4.

The settlement follows the earlier $75,000 payment to Thomas Manis and adds to growing public scrutiny of DUI enforcement procedures in Tennessee.

Other civil claims involving allegedly improper DUI arrests remain active, meaning additional legal developments could follow.

For Fair, the approved settlement represents the conclusion of her compensation dispute with the state, although the incident has continued to attract media attention because of her background in the entertainment industry.

Final Thoughts

Stefanie Fair's $70,000 settlement follows a 2024 Nashville DUI arrest in which the arresting trooper claimed to smell alcohol, despite Fair repeatedly denying that she had been drinking.

Subsequent blood testing found no alcohol or drugs in her system, and the criminal charge was dismissed.

The case has also become part of a wider investigation into alleged wrongful DUI arrests in Tennessee, with other drivers pursuing compensation through lawsuits against law enforcement agencies.

Beyond the celebrity connection, Fair's case raises important questions about the reliability of roadside sobriety assessments, the protection of drivers' constitutional rights, and the financial consequences of arrests that are not supported by later evidence.